Former Taiwan VP offer neutral solution to Japan-China territorial dispute

Former Taiwan VP offer neutral solution to Japan-China territorial dispute

With the two Asian superpowers, Japan and China, on the verge of taking military action against each other over a cluster of uninhabited islands, Taiwan’s former vice president, Annette Lu Hsiu-lien, has offered a somewhat simple solution—enter into a treaty. She points out that while both countries are fighting over who has the better claim over the Senkaku / Diaoyu Islands, it is in fact Taiwan who has the best claim of them all.

She says that not only are the islands, Diaoyutais to the Taiwanese, geographically closer to Taiwan’s territory, they are also made of igneous rocks, whose “chemical and geographic characteristics are the same as Taiwan’s Mt. Datun….” Lu proposes a demilitarization of the islands and for all three claimants—Japan, China and Taiwan—to enter into a compromise through the cooperation of the United Nations. Indeed, Taiwan also showed that it is enforcing its claim on the Japan-controlled islands when President Ma Ying-jeou sent a military escort with fishing ships into the area. According to Lu, territorial sovereignty over the islands should not be allowed, in order to preserve the status quo and stability therein. Instead, the area should be developed as an international marine conservation zone; the development being purely made for peaceful purposes.

While Lu is not currently a member of the Taiwanese government, she remains to be very influential to the country’s citizens. Furthermore, this Harvard graduate is known for her active campaign against adding a third nuclear power plant in Taiwan.

[via World Tribune]
Share Button
DISCUSS IT
Comment Policy : Our comments section is open and welcome to anyone who wishes to participate in discussion or share their point of view, regardless of what it may be. In order to limit spam and those who wish to impede meaningful conversation, we are now requiring users to log in with an account or verify their email address. However, the following behavior will result in your comment being deleted or, if continued, permanent removal from conversations: posting under multiple names, making hateful/racist comments, or making no valuable contribution by posting the same thing repeatedly.
  • Far East

    And I propose that territorial soverignty of Taiwan should not be allowed, and instead that Taiwan “be developed as an international marine conservation zone; the development being purely made for peaceful purposes.”
    How’s that for disposing of another country’s sovereign territory hu ?

    • A.C.

      >>some people should really jus tthink twice before expressing such nonsense.

      They should first think at all I’d suggest.

    • Guest

      Exactly.

    • Whirled Peas

      And America’s 13 colonies should go back to the English, who should in turn hand them back to any number of native tribes, and if any of those tribes had taken their land by force from another tribe, they too should return the land to their rightful native owner, who in turn… etc. ad nauseum. And since the written record is imperfect, modern-day representatives of these tribes will have to rely on the conflicting memories of tribal elders and instead of moving forward, all of America (or whatever you’d call it) will be absurdly stuck in the past.

  • A.C.

    That’s actually not a new argument … There will never be a solution, if they don’t acknowledge that historic events create factual situations. If everyone would act that way, Germany would have to claim baclk it’s former Western parts of nowadays Poland, while Poland had to reclaim it’s West that after WWII became part of the Soviet Union. If you don’t accept that history creates hard facts, you could trace your claims all back through history.

    • Far East

      Yes, I completely agree.

  • Chopchop2012

    What will you say if the Taiwan and Senkaku Island’s rock’s chemical and geographic characteristics are the same as Okinawa?
    Will she recognize Taiwan belong to Japan?
    Current owner own the Island.

  • Whirled Peas

    “She points out that while both countries are fighting over who has the better claim over the Senkaku / Diaoyu Islands, it is in fact Taiwan who has the BEST claim of them all.”

    If Taiwan’s “best claim” is based on proximity to Taiwan and common mineral composition, then the PRC (mainland) has no claim at all! Proximity and minerals don’t count. I urge the former Taiwan VP to read up on international law. The strongest precedent on island disputes is the Island of Palmas case (1928) See link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island_of_Palmas_Case

    • Far East

      Very interesting reference !

  • joe

    i think it is fair to acknowledged that those rocks belongs to Taiwan for many reason. However, having said that, the same logic should apply that those rocks will eventually belong to China once we unify under one country 2 systems. It may take longer for this to happen but this is the only feasible solution.