Okinawa belongs to China, some nationalists claim

Okinawa belongs to China, some nationalists claim

While Japan and China are still engaged in a territorial squabble over the Senkaku group of islands (Diaoyu in China), some Chinese nationalistic groups are already making other claims on Japanese soil. According to these groups, there is historical basis to prove that the island of Okinawa belongs to China.

Okinawa, the largest in the Ryukyu group of islands which extend from the southwest tip of mainland Japan up to Taiwan, was the center of the Ryukyuan kingdom. The kingdom, situated in between two kingdoms, swore fealty to both Chinese and Japanese lords. Ryukyu was involved with China’s Ming and Qing dynasties as well as Japanese feudal lords, until it was absorbed totally by Japan in 1879, under demand for its complete loyalty to the Japanese empire. Ethnic and linguistic analysis put the people of Okinawa closer to Japanese mainland, but some Chinese believe China has stronger relations. In the Beijing Imperial Museum, an 18th century book written during the Qing dynasty talks about how Ryukyuan students were culturally equal to Chinese students. The Imperial college back then trained both Imperial officials and foreign students.

The Chinese government had not made any claim, but some say that it is secretly encouraging such ideas. State-controlled media have made statements and comments questioning Japanese ownership of the island. The People’s Liberation Army have made a statement, carried by state media, about Ryukyu’s independence as a kingdom under China before it was seized by Japan. Some demonstrators protesting the Senkaku incident have been seen to carry signs reading “Take back Okinawa.” Scholars from both Japan and Western countries state that the historical ties with China are not enough to warrant claims of sovereignty over the island. Residents of Okinawa still can’t help but worry over possible repercussions of the worsening situation between Japan and China, some of whom still remember the bloody battle between U.S. and Japanese forces in 1945. The U.S. has military facilities on Okinawa, raising fears of being a possible target in military actions against either Japan or the U.S.

[via France 24]
Share Button
DISCUSS IT
Comment Policy : Our comments section is open and welcome to anyone who wishes to participate in discussion or share their point of view, regardless of what it may be. In order to limit spam and those who wish to impede meaningful conversation, we are now requiring users to log in with an account or verify their email address. However, the following behavior will result in your comment being deleted or, if continued, permanent removal from conversations: posting under multiple names, making hateful/racist comments, or making no valuable contribution by posting the same thing repeatedly.
  • sdfqef

    Some Japanese nationalist also claim that Rape of Nanking never happened. But you don’t see Chinese nationalist writing articles about that during this time trying to inflame the situation. It’s so petty for Japanese to try and shift blame at this time.

  • http://twitter.com/dragonflown Anon

    Actually sdfqef, we see it all the time. Chinese riot, loot, and burn whenever they hear that!

  • http://twitter.com/dragonflown Anon

    That is not to say that the Chinese aren’t right, it will be determined by whoever wants it more, and right now it sounds like the Chinese want it more, and they have the means to make Japan cower.
    Basically the strong beating the meek.

  • sengleong

    Ida Torres,

    Your article is mischievious and in my opinion you are intending to forment unnecessary hatred between Chinese and Japanese people. China had not claimed Okinawa as you purported stated. Your article does not carry any factual research nor does it have any concrete findings. This is a disgrace.